PLAYER RATINGS: Dottin catch wins the day as England produce faltering display

The Cricketer looks at the individual performances from England's Women's World Cup defeat against West Indies

WEST INDIES

Deandra Dottin (31; 0-22): Would have fallen to the first ball of the match without Winfield-Hill's drop, and smashed Shrubsole for six but otherwise couldn't get going and a meandering innings was ended by a farcical runout; took a sensational catch at backward point that changed the game 7

Hayley Matthews (45; 2-40): Played beautifully and looked in terrific touch, punching through the offside and, given how England fielded, unfortunate to be caught at short third man; bowled beautifully for the key scalps of Knight and Sciver 7

Kycia Knight (6): A poor outing that began by running out Dottin with a non-existent single, before ending when she slapped Ecclestone at cover 2

Stafanie Taylor (0; 1-21): Fell first ball to a cracking delivery from Ecclestone that turned and bounced, catching her glove on the way through; not at her best with the ball but claimed the key breakthrough of Dunkley 4

Shemaine Campbelle (66): Made her second ODI fifty just when it looked as though England might take control – a fine knock 8

Chedean Nation (49*): Provided excellent support for Campbelle, ending one short of a deserved half century 6

^{Tammy Beaumont made 46 for England (Sanka Vidanagama/AFP via Getty Images)}

Chinelle Henry (0; 0-15): Struggled with her line but fielded well and took the key catches of Dunkley and Wyatt 4

Aaliyah Alleyne (0*; 1-31): Bowled tidily and had Jones caught at slip; delivered one of three maidens in England's innings 6

Shamilia Connell (3-38): Wayward at times in her first spell but grew into the game, claiming Winfield-Hill before returning to pick up the key wickets of Wyatt and Brunt in the same over 7

Anisa Mohammed (2-24): Inadvertently ran out Cross before ending the game by bowling Shrubsole, having earlier claimed he key wicket of Beaumont 6

Shakera Selman (0-24): Bowled nicely without success in a fine team performance 5

ENGLAND 

Lauren Winfield-Hill (12): Dropped a sitter and later was brilliantly caught by Dottin with the bat 3

Tammy Beaumont (46): Played with typical poise until missing a full ball from Mohammed just short of another fifty 6

Heather Knight (5; 0-22): Unlucky to be dismissed cheaply, if only because West Indies' fielders were themselves surprised to learn she'd edged a Matthews delivery; bowled nicely as the second spinner on a pitch that suggested England might have also picked Charlie Dean 4

Natalie Sciver (2; 1-49): Fell to an uncharacteristic miscue as the pressure built on her after a spell of tight bowling; loose with the ball 3

Amy Jones (1): Impeccable behind the stumps on a day that she was not helped by her bowlers; short on runs with the bat 3

Danni Wyatt (33): Counterattacked well with Dunkley but played a poor shot just after the fall a wicket at the other end, when England could have done with a period of consolidation 6

^{Deandra Dottin took a remarkable catch to get rid of Lauren Winfield-Hill (Sanka Vidanagama/AFP via Getty Images)}

Sophia Dunkley (38): Played well until mistiming a pull shot off Taylor to be caught at short midwicket 6

Katherine Brunt (1; 0-38): Too short with the new ball and picked off easily; didn't bowl her full allocation and fell cheaply with the bat 5

Sophie Ecclestone (33*; 3-20): England would have been in plenty of trouble without the left-arm spinner, who claimed two wickets in the same over to wake up her team after a poor start; excellent with the bat and unfortunate to be left stranded at the end 8

Kate Cross (27; 0-36): The best of England's seamers by a distance, bowling cannily through the middle overs and only wicketless because she dropped a chance off her own bowling; terrific partnership with Ecclestone that was ended unfortunately 6

Anya Shrubsole (0; 0-57): Expensive with the ball and poor in the field, dropping two straightforward chances; will be lucky to hold onto her place for England's third game 2