Head coach Chris Silverwood is willing the pair to produce their best - an indication they could remain in the team at Emirates Old Trafford
Jos Buttler and Joe Denly have been given a vote of confidence ahead of England's second Test against West Indies at Emirates Old Trafford.
Of the players to feature in the four-wicket defeat at The Ageas Bowl, the Lancashire and Kent stars are perhaps most vulnerable.
While Buttler scored 35 and 9 with the bat - he also dropped matchwinner Jermaine Blackwood during the Windies chase - Denly registered knocks of 18 and 29.
Indeed, with captain Joe Root returning to the XI, the Kent batsman could be dropped, particularly after Zak Crawley impressed again in Southampton.
Head coach Chris Silverwood appears set to keep faith with the troubled 34-year-old and admits the whole team are willing him to succeed.
Ben Foakes is the designated back-up to Jos Buttler
"We're all desperate to see Joe do really well," he said of Denly, who averages 29.53 and is yet to score a century in his 28 Test innings. "You can see that he is trying hard and training well and he's a great bloke, hence why we want to see him do well. He's probably feeling the pressure a little bit."
Crawley enhanced his selection credentials with a fine 76 in the second innings to help build England's lead - a fine knock which saw him up the rate and turn the Test on its head. It remains to be seen whether the second half-century of his short international career will be enough to see him remain but Silverwood was an impressed spectator.
"He certainly showed maturity and the innings he played was very good. We've got some young players in that side that have some good heads on their shoulders.
"I thought the innings he played was really good. We would have liked to have seen him go on and potentially get to those three figures. But what he did was very good and helped us get into a good position.
"That's what we're looking for. If we can create an environment where those guys can continually learn then we're going to end up with some very good cricketers on our hands. That's what we're trying to do. Zak is improving constantly."
Zak Crawley could miss out in Manchester despite his half-century at The Ageas Bowl
Further down the order Buttler's position is perhaps more secure yet remains under scrutiny. Surrey's Ben Foakes is his deputy in the group, with Jonny Bairstow having moved to the white-ball bubble, but with little recent cricket to go on the man in possession looks set to remain.
With just one century in 42 Tests and a single fifty in his last 21 innings, it remains a mystery why Buttler has been unable to transfer his white-ball form into the longest format. But if Silverwood's comments are any indication, the Lancashire man will be given every opportunity to recapture his best form.
"He looked brilliant coming into this game, in practice and everything and looked good in the first innings," he added.
"He just needs to make those big scores now. From our point of view, it is just making sure he feels comfortable in the environment he is in so that he can succeed.
"I am not going to go down that road of putting Jos under pressure because I don't think it is going to help him. First and foremost we are going to give Jos the best opportunity to succeed. We have a very, very good gloveman in Ben Foakes who we're lucky to have."
Save 30% when you subscribe to The Cricketer’s print & digital bundle. £35 for 12 issues
Posted by Marc Evans on 14/07/2020 at 22:57
Whatever reservations there are about both Buttler and Denley is there a realistic alternative to cover their respective roles in the side. Denley is the occupier of the crease, which he did with some skill in the 1st innings and Buttler taking them on, as he also did to some effect in the 1st innings. Buttler particularly is also Ed Smith's project, to prove a white ball player can make it in the red ball game. As he's not good enough for a top 6 role as a batsman he has to be used as a keeper to justify his selection. Even Bairstow is a better keeper and Foakes is in a different class, but with a deliberate top order 5,6 and 7 can offset this with dominant stroke play to capitalise on the blunting of an attack. However this comes unstuck when your keeper drops crucial catches, as Buttler did off Blackwood, which may have cost us the test. With no competitive cricket in the offing outside the tests its difficult to see any significant changes in selection for this series. Broad may come in for Wood, who once again disappointed, despite his pace , but no young Turk is going to come out of the woodwork to score hundreds against this present Windies attack.
Posted by John Nicholls on 14/07/2020 at 17:50
One fifty in 21 innings, and Silverwood says “we want to make him feel comfortable” ! I would suggest he’s been on the sofa for the last 10 of those knocks.... Foakes is a better keeper and batsman. Too many sacred cows in that team. We are not going to regain the Ashes unless we make some difficult decisions now!!!
Posted by Peter Brookes on 14/07/2020 at 17:27
It is astonishing that Ben Foakes is not keeping wicket. Apart from being a better keeper than Buttler he is a more secure batsman and in the long run will score more runs. Buttler has had many chances. It is time for him to be left out.
Posted by Les Bone on 14/07/2020 at 16:52
If both Denly and Buttler play this week I will start to think that Silverwood is losing the plot. Questions also about the judgement of Ed Smith and whether he is the right man in the right job.
Posted by The Deano on 14/07/2020 at 15:34
Can't believe they're going to stick with Denly and Butler.The 'favoured ' are given limitless opportunities whilst those less fortunate are cast away or treated with suspicion even after performing.Foakes is an infinitely better wicket keeper than Butler with a higher first class batting average, not forgetting the Butler last day dropped catch which probably cost match.
Posted by Simon Wardle on 14/07/2020 at 11:57
With Ben Foakes being the best gloveman he should be first choice. You want your best team and Foakes is your best man in that position