Pink ball is rubbish, says unimpressed Yorkshire chief exec Arthur

HUW TURBERVILL: Yorkshire chief executive Mark Arthur gives his verdict on the pink-ball round and says the counties have never been more unified


The pink ball has drawn plenty of detractors

The County Championship featured a pink-ball day/night round for a second successive year and the verdict was not favourable.

“I think it’s rubbish, and you can quote me on that,” Yorkshire chief executive Mark Arthur told The Cricketer

Hampshire and Yorkshire, in Division One, and Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire, in Division Two, ditched the red ball from June 20–23, then another five matches were played a week later (two in the top flight, three in the lower tier).

“It undermines the quality of the County Championship,” said Arthur. “Hampshire would normally get 1,700 spectators when Yorkshire turn up. They had half of that, and for the last hour, there were 100 people left in the ground, and that is disrespectful to our cricket-watching public. We had more than 8,000 on the first two days at Scarborough (v Surrey) and it was not even the festival. 

“You have to be really careful that experiments for the ECB are not to the detriment of county cricket, and I think that is one that is. The players do not like it; you cannot see the ball at a certain time, to the side of the wicket; the quality of the ball was shocking. Why are we doing it?”


Yorkshire in County Championship action

A pink ball made by Kookaburra was used in Division One, to accustom players to the ones used in overseas day/night Tests, with Dukes in Division Two. According to CricketArchive, 154 wickets fell at an average of 32.17 in the first two sessions of all days of the matches; 53 at an average of 49.11 apiece in Division One, and 101 at 23.28 in Division Two.

In the third and final (post-dinner) sessions, 75 wickets fell at 28.12 in total: 33 at 34.55 in the top flight, and 42 at 23.07 in the tier below. So the pink ball favours the bowlers, but what about the other reason for the experiment – boosting crowds? It seems many fans did not stay until the end of the matches.

Some of the counties are becoming increasingly anxious about the Championship, and this pink-ball round has not improved the mood.

“I think the counties are seeking to protect the three forms of cricket which they are in charge of – the Championship, which is seen as the pinnacle, the Blast and the One-Day Cup,” said Arthur.

“Someone has to stand up for county cricket, and unless we do, no one else will. Certainly there is a great unity. I have been involved in professional cricket for 28 years now, and I have never seen such unity between the 18 first-class counties.

"Now that the ECB is totally independent of county cricket, who is going to be making decisions about county cricket? Is it those people with knowledge, or those without?"

"We are going through quite a bit of dialogue with the ECB over what cricket looks like; there’s Wasim Khan’s group, but there are lots of different groups. I am on the ‘what is the purpose of a first-class county?’ group, chaired by Gordon Hollins, and the ECB are listening. Rob Andrew (Sussex), Will Brown (Gloucestershire), Andrew Cornish (Somerset) and Martin Darlow (Bedfordshire) are also on it.

“The key things about these groups is, will they listen, and will they act upon what comes out of these meetings? And I hope they do, because now that the ECB is totally independent of county cricket, who is going to be making decisions about county cricket? Is it those people with knowledge, or those without?”

The obvious reason why counties do not want to form a breakaway group is the money they receive from the ECB (about £2m per year, plus an additional £1.3m annually when The 100 starts).

Asked if a rival group might be formed, he said: “I don’t know. My preference would be not. My preference would be for a stronger group within the auspices of the ECB.”

Yorkshire want the introduction of a conference system for the Championship. “We [certainly] don’t want any fewer matches,” Arthur said.

“The conference system would give you 15. [Yorkshire director of cricket] Martyn Moxon is on that working party. Our summers are not long enough to play all the cricket we want, so you are never going to get the perfect formula. We want to protect the county game while giving England the best opportunity of winning.”

The Cricketer is available in all good newsagents or through our online shop

Click here for subscriptions



STAY UP TO DATE Sign up to our weekly newsletter...

Thank You! Thank you for subscribing!


Court House, Cleaver Street, London SE11 4DZ


Welcome to www.thecricketer.com - the online home of the world’s oldest cricket magazine. Breaking news, interviews, opinion and cricket goodness from every corner of our beautiful sport, from village green to national arena.